"Smart
questions are essential technology for those who venture on to
the Information Highway"
Jamie
McKenzie .. editor of the educational technology journal,
From
Now On
Closed questions
Research shows that teachers can sometimes ask
a question every 2-3 seconds. Unfortunately, these questions are
usually just asking students to remember facts. These are called
recall questions and often fall into a category of questions
known as closed or convergent questions. Closed questions
normally have a correct answer and often this is a "yes"
or a "no".
Examples of closed questions:
- What is the height of Table Mountain?
- What is the capital of Zimbabwe?
- What did we do in the last lesson?
- Do you want to go to the soccer match?
Learners' questions
The best questions in the class are those
that are asked by the learners themselves. If learners are encouraged
to ask questions they will become lifelong learners. Sometimes learners
need some easy closed questions to get them started. Sometimes teachers
use closed questions to test their learners' research skills, in
which case the teacher is trying to develop the search skills and
not necessarily the thinking skills
Closed questions are not always bad.
It is sometimes necessary to recap on work done and to assess whether
learners understand something. However, if you only ever use closed
questions, then you are never going to encourage your learners to
think.
Open questions
As an educator,
you should use open or divergent questions as much as possible
to encourage the learners to think. Open questions are not answered
with a simple answer. Often there is more than one possible correct
answer. Certainly the learner has to think a while before an open
question can be answered. Open questions help learners to formulate
opinions and allow them to make informed decisions.
Quite often open questions start
with one of the three big questioning words: How? Why? and Which?
If we use How, Why and Which we are very
unlikely to get a Yes or No answer. Look back at the
table that gave examples of such questions under the
previous section called, "Why ask Questions". Do
you notice the importance of the wording?
Examples of open questions are:
Why
do you think the Zulu king Dingane attacked the voortrekker leader
Pier Retief?
Well, only Dingane knows for sure. Historians
have grappled with this question for decades. Incidentally, "Why?"
is used most commonly by learners in the primary phase. Why do teachers
and learners stop using this word in higher school levels?
Why do schools get vandalised?
The
"Why?" question often causes the learner to analyse a
situation and offer an opinion based on evidence.
How do I improve my questioning techniques?
Well, practice makes perfect, but there are
several answers to this question. The "how?" question
often leaves the learner with a problem to solve and the reply often
describes plenty of action.
What did you like about that movie/ food/ dentist
?
This
question is more likely to get a detailed response than "Did
you like it?"
Which
school should I send my child to?
This word "Which"
often leaves the learner with a decision to make;
"A good question is never answered. It is not a bolt to
be tightened into place but a seed to be planted and to bear more
seed toward the hope of greening the landscape of idea."
John Anthony Ciardi (1916-86) American
poet, critic
Samples of closed and open questions:
Topic
|
Closed questions
|
Open questions
|
History |
When did the Khoi
move into what is now the Cape? |
Why did the Khoi
move to what is now the Cape? |
Geography
|
Who was the first
astronaut? |
Which planet,
other than Earth would you prefer to visit and why? |
Science |
What are two
elements of water? |
Why is it important
to purify water before drinking it? |
Maths |
What is the definition
of a triangle? |
How have triangles
influenced architecture? |
|