"Questions are the fuel on which
real learning exists"
Jamie McKenzie
(Beyond
Technology: Questioning, Research and the Information Literate
School (FNO Press, 2000)
If you look at the module on Using
web resources, you will see that
there is a section on staying current. This is often a springboard
for your learners to become interested in a current topic, such
as the Olympics or the International Aids Conference or the Soccer
World Cup because they can hear about it on the radio and some may
be lucky enough to follow the event on the television. After
identifying an event such as these that interest your learners then
you can start to motivate them to phrase questions for research.
We need to challenge learners with thought-provoking
questions rather than presenting them with tasks such as, "Do
a project on Gauteng." Instead, give learners a real problem,
such as where would they like to live in South Africa? You could
give an example of statistics of the number of murders committed
in each town. Then you could ask learners to answer questions such
as the following:
- Which city had the worst murder rate in 2000?
- Which city has the fastest rate of decline
in its murder rate today?
- Which regions of the country are most dangerous
Phrasing questions for projects
As
we have discovered in previous pages, asking questions is quite
an art. If we ask the right type of questions we are
going to make our learners think and if we don't then they are just
going to repeat what we have told them. Higher order questions
require time for learners to think about the answers. To build
on Bloom's
taxonomy again, higher level thinking
- Knowledge: define, label, list, memorize,
name, order, recognize, reproduce, state.
- Comprehension: describe, discuss, explain,
express, identify, indicate, locate,
- Application: apply, demonstrate, dramatize,
illustrate, practice, schedule, use,
- Analysis: calculate, categorize, compare,
contrast, distinguish, experiment, test.
- Synthesis: arrange, collect, construct, create,
design, plan, prepare, propose, set up,
- Evaluation: appraise, assess, defend, estimate,
judge, predict, rate, support, value,
"For the best answers, ask
tough questions."
(The Philadelphia Inquirer, April 20, 2000 tech.k12 / Joyce Kasman
Valenza)
It
is clear that the teacher has an important duty to make sure that
the questions that they ask are stimulating and thought provoking.
Just compare these instructions for projects:
Encourages copying
(Finding answers) |
Encourages inquiry
(Making answers) |
1. Do a project on Cholera |
1. How could the outbreak of Cholera in KZN and Mpumalanga
have been avoided? (note that there was an outbreak
of cholera in KZN and Mpumalanga at the time of writing
these materials) |
2. Go and find out about AIDS |
2. What is the relationship between AIDS and poverty?
|
3. Do a project on photosynthesis.
|
3. What would happen if all plants
stopped photosynthesizing for a year? |
4. Find out about supply and demand
|
4. Predict the future of South
Africa's gold mines. |
5. Do a project on King Shaka |
5. What would you imagine life
to be like if you were a soldier in one of King Shaka's
regiments. |
6. Do a project on South African housing |
6.What factors have influenced the different kinds of houses
people live in in your area? |
Can you see the
difference between these two columns? The copying
column is not stimulating or challenging in any way, whereas
the questions in the inquiry column are guaranteed to spark
curiosity and allow learners to engage their thinking and
problem-solving skills. |
In questions such as these in the
right hand column, the educator's role is to encourage learners
to work with information rather than simply find the right answer
to the question.
A Grade 3 class at a
primary school in a large suburb of Tempe in central Arizona, wanted
to do a study on the flowers and animals in the desert. Instead
of asking the children to do a project on "The plants and animals
found in the desert", the teachers asked them to investigate
: How do plants and animals interact and depend on one another for
food and shelter? To read about how they planned the project have
a look at the teacher's reflections at
http://www.wested.org/tales/07desert09.html
If
you would like to see how the simple Grade 3 project on the desert
turned out, have a look at
http://seamonkey.ed.asu.edu/~storslee/botan.html
Have a look at a South African example, included
on your CD Healing
the nation.
|