| Panel
Group: |
Student: |
| Points |
0 |
1 |
2 |
3 |
| Criteria |
|
|
|
|
| Level of understanding of the
subject matter demonstrated by presenter |
not much at
all |
a minimal
amount |
a respectable
amount |
a tremendous
amount |
| Logical organization of
information presented |
impossible to
follow |
difficult to
follow |
somewhat
clear |
extremely
clear |
| Information presented covers all
subsidiary questions or subtopics |
no questions or
subtopics covered |
few questions or
subtopics covered |
most questions or
subtopics covered |
all questions or
subtopics covered |
| Enthusiasm of presenter about
the topic |
not at all
enthusiastic |
seemed mildly
interested |
seemed very
interested |
obviously very
enthusiastic |
| Level of oral communication
skills exhibited by presenter |
extremely
poor |
minimally
adequate |
acceptable |
excellent |
| Effort reflected in
presentation |
hardly any at
all |
enough to "get
by" |
a respectable
amount |
a tremendous
amount |
| Demonstration of courtesy to
other panel members |
extremely
poor |
minimally
adequate |
acceptable |
excellent |
| Length of presentation followed
time requirement |
inadequate |
acceptable |
good |
excellent |
| Responses to audience
questions |
inadequate |
acceptable |
good |
excellent |
| Subtotals |
|
|
|
|
| |
Total Points |
|